Searching for Insight
Many who belong to art clubs or just starting out are artists; or haven’t put in long hours/years of study with a qualified teacher, will invariably seek the advice of anyone willing to give it. Some others, who may have taken the time or spent money on a qualified teacher, ignore or dismiss the criticism given by that teacher. I have experienced this first hand. They just want to paint. Methods, techniques and a concepts are a minor nuisance at best. It is easier, they say, to get someone they admire, to tell them what is wrong with their work than try and work it out in their head on their own. They remain ill-equipped to recognize the good from the bad in their work.
Professional artists, by comparison, already know what is wrong with their work and don’t rely on outside speculation. If they can’t figure it out by themselves, something is surely lacking in their training and/or experience. They haven’t fully spent sufficient time necessary in realizing their inability to recognize when a piece is good, or when it needs more work.
There is an inherent problem for artists’ willing to take criticism from the horde of untalented, uninformed non painters ready and willing to give “unasked for” criticism.
Who among us isn’t willing to say what they really think of an artist’s work? Everyone today has an opinion, not only on art but on every subject imaginable.
Practically speaking, only after painting for many years, coupled with the experiences of failure, does one know when something is wrong with their work. Also after many years of painting, you put aside your ego and critique your work honestly without bias. Anyone still wanting for outside critique is fishing for compliments and doesn’t really want to hear what is seriously wrong.
Another pitfall is that when you ask for “pointers”, they will speak from what they themselves believe to be correct and subsequently therefore it has no value to the person asking for advice in the first place.
The beauty and wonder of creating art is that it is a process of discovery; not only concerning art but also a discovery of self. When you seek to understand the processes of paint, you also seek to understand and gain knowledge of more than yourself. This concept may sound foreign to many but to an artist, this is at the core of making art. When you stop asking what’s wrong and acquire the knowledge and experience to know what’s right, is when your work improves.
If you are a devotee of art or an aspiring student, here are some hints to where the problems may lie in your work. Look to composition, then, move to form, pattern, paint application, subject, value or concept. When you understand these ideas- you will have a better understanding of what is right and what is wrong with your work. You will have no need to ask for advice.

